Local Pies Using Local Ingredients!

Thanksgiving is a big deal at Walden, and while we’re experts in things like pasture-raised turkeys and sustainable farming, we’re always eager to learn from other small companies who share our mission and vision. Every year, we seek to align ourselves with other local businesses to bring our members new and exciting offerings to add to their holiday shares! With pies, one must look no further than Petsi Pies.

Founded back in 2003, Petsi Pies has been baking up delicious creations in Somerville, MA and we’re so excited to have them providing us with both pumpkin and apple pies this year. What makes these pies truly unique though is that they’ll be made using Walden’s pasture-raised eggs, our 100% grass-fed, A2, organic whole milk, and our amazing 100% grass-fed butter!

Local pies using local ingredients!

Get your hands on these delicious pies now by building a Thanksgiving Share from your Member Page. Thank you for supporting our mission! This is local at work!

Order Your Thanksgiving Share Here!

Photo Below: Owner Jill Remby in her Somerville shop!


I actually rendered a big batch of leaf lard from my share and have made 4 apple pies this year from apples in my local CSA! I grew up learning how to make pies from my late father and it’s been nice making a bunch of pies again after petering back since moving to the city.

My usual is 50% lard/50% butter. Makes an amazing balance of flaky and tender.

I’ve also been making extra dough for my husband–one of his specialties is pasties made with walden sausage, usually the garlic-pepper.Tastes great with cabbage or turnips mixed in.

1 Like

Wow! That all sounds amazing! If you have any favorite recipes that are not secret, I’d love to give them a try. There’s something special about a homemade pie :slight_smile:

1 Like

Seconding the request for recipes!! These sound amazing. My dad has been getting into pies lately and I would love to rival him with a Walden lard based pie. And your husband’s pasties sound delicious!!!


Happy to share! <3 Always glad to see people interested in the NE tradition of pie baking.

If you’ve never rendered leaf lard, here’s instructions on how to do it. It looks more daunting than it actually is–if you WFH, it’s as simple as cutting it into bite sized pieces, taking off any meat chunks, and covering the pot with water. Then just cook it low and slow all day until the water is evaporated and there’s nothing but cracklings left. (I usually cover the pot once the water is evaporated out to prevent splatter.) I should also say–Walden’s leaf lard packs make a HUGE amount of lard, so you get a good effort:output ratio. 1 pack made four 24-oz tupperwares of lard (almost a gallon). Make sure you wait 30 mins to an hour before pouring the lard in a container.

My crust recipe for a 9-10" two crust pie is:

-2.5 cups flour
-teaspoon salt
-1/2 cup butter, unsalted (cut back the salt if you use salted butter)
-1/2 cup rendered pork lard
-ice water, which I just add 2-3 tablespoons at a time until it coheres, but it’s usually between 2/3 to 1 cup.

You can get great in-depth pie crust instructions from King Arthur Flour’s website, but here’s a few tips and tricks I’ve picked up over the years:
-Butter is more idiot proof than lard or crisco–butter really resists incorporating into the flour and water, so it guarantees a flakier crust. Conversely, it’s makes the crust harder to work with.
-When you roll your crust, roll out in one direction rather than back and forth, and use the handled-style rolling pin. You can put a lot more force in your strokes that way. It’s hard for me to explain what I mean… I might try to make a gif next time I bake a pie…

Other tips/thoughts:
-My favorite filling thickener is potato starch. You can use this 1:1 in place of flour. It thickens perfectly clear and doesn’t taste grainy.
-For pumpkin pie, it always tastes better with a fresh pumpkin. This may be confirmation bias.
-Chocolate Pie is similarly a cut above when you use homemade pudding.

here are my favorite pie recipes! It doesn’t let me put more than 2 links in a post, so for all the KAF recipes, you can look them up on King Arthur Flour’s website.
*KAF’s apple pie: I use rum in place of cider. Use the classic recipe, not the “secret” one.
*KAF’s pumpkin pie: I used to hate pumpkin pie until I went with this recipe.
*KAF’s Chocolate Pie: My favorite not-fruit pie.
*Rhubarb Pie: A dying pie flavor, but my husband’s favorite (and my 2nd after Raspberry). Better than strawberry Rhubarb IMHO.

I’ll try to write down what my husband does exactly next time he makes pasties. It’s definitely a “whatever we got in our veggie share” recipe a lot of the time!